Did Monica ever say she was an MSW? I'm not even sure those ethical standards apply to her (maybe, maybe not). In any event, I do not agree with your interpretation of these ethical guidelines. Yes, we are supposed to educate ourselves about diversity and advocate for social justice. I don't see how that relates to some doped-up wife beater pounding on her door to continue his assault on Monica's neighbor? Nor does it relate to the exact process she is going through: working through her feelings, seeking supervision, and accepting feedback. That IS the ethical thing to do. He is not being denied anything. No rights have been violated, and there is no harm but that which he caused. How does this violent, substance abuser all of a sudden become the victim and Monica the perpetrator? In my opinion, that position is untenable. So is the position that we have specific ethical obligations to individuals (not society, we're talking about one individual) who are not our clients. That would make the profession essentially unworkable. So many people remain ill because they do not accept responsibility for their actions, nor do they accept the consequences of their behavior. Blaming Monica for this situation is frankly beyond me. Linking it to failed marriage therapy and general ethical standards of MSW's is also beyond me. I'm trying very hard (since Dr. Reid thinks I'm the problem) to see your point of view here, but it just doesn't make sense. Other than making sure she does not interfere with his actual treatment (wherever that may end up being) Monica owes this guy exactly nothing. I sure wish other therapists would chime in here...
Replies:
|
| Behavior OnLine Home Page | Disclaimer |
Copyright © 1996-2004 Behavior OnLine, Inc. All rights reserved.