Thread: Hello
View Single Post
  #7  
Unread July 9th, 2006, 10:16 AM
alexandra_k alexandra_k is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 106
Default Re: Hello

if sound is a property of the external environment that typically causes the experience of sound in normal observers under normal conditions (just try cashing that out lol) then yes.

if sound is a property of the observer that is typically caused by the vibrations in the world then no.

what about: can i hear a sound of a tree falling when there is no tree falling?

if sound is a property of the external environment that typically causes the experience of sound in normal observers under normal conditions (just try cashing that out lol) then no.

if sound is a property of the observer that is typically caused by the vibrations in the world then yes.

(typically people worry about colour, but sound is kinda interesting too).
(some people think perceiving - hence seeing and hearing is a success term so if you see / hear x then that entails x. other people disagree)

is it same or different in the case of pain do ya think?

if i have the experience of pain in my left toe but my left leg has been amputated then is there pain in my left toe?

if i have the experience of pain in my left toe but my left leg has been amputated then am i in pain?

seems that there is this causal process:

vibrations -> experience
bodily damage -> experience

we can call vibrations (the objective aspect) sound1 and the phenomenology / experience sound2
we can call bodily damage (the objective aspect) pain1 and the phenomenology / experience pain2

in our everyday lives most people think we tend to go with sound1 and pain2.
there is thus an a-symmetry between sounds / colours, and pains. interesting... that is the problem of focus. why focus on the external object in the case of vision / sound but focus on the phenomenology in the case of pain?
Reply With Quote